SAN FRANCISCO — On a bright Sunday afternoon at Oracle Park, an unexpected turn of events saw the Giants employing an “opener” strategy outperform the Dodgers’ starting pitcher in what ended up being a disappointing game for the visitors.

James Paxton, the Dodgers’ left-handed starter, endured a rough outing, surrendering nine earned runs and 12 hits over just four innings, contributing to a 10-4 loss against the Giants. This performance starkly contrasted his recent success, leaving the Dodgers struggling to maintain their bullpen’s stamina following a demanding game the day before.

In contrast, Spencer Bivens, a 30-year-old rookie stepping in for the Giants, delivered an impressive first major league start. Expected to pitch only a couple of innings, Bivens lasted five, letting in just one run on four hits and striking out three without issuing a walk.

Paxton, who had been previously steadfast in his starts, could not evade the Giants’ offense, allowing hits with significant exit velocities and struggling to adapt to the hitters’ anticipation of his fastball. Despite his desire to push through for the team, Paxton was pulled after his pitch count escalated, a move that Dodgers manager Dave Roberts defended, prioritizing the pitcher’s health.

The Giants assaulted Paxton early, establishing a commanding lead that the Dodgers’ bullpen, albeit efficient in the later innings, could not overturn. The situation was dire enough that discussions about using infielders as pitchers were on the table, signifying the strain on the Dodgers’ bullpen resources.

Amid the Dodgers’ struggles, Chris Taylor emerged as a silver lining, demonstrating newfound form with a homer and a double, and earning more playing time at third base—a position left vulnerable by Max Muncy’s absence due to an injury.

For the Giants, it was a day where their offensive might shone brightly, with notable performances across the board contributing to a significant victory over their rivals. This game underscored the unpredictable nature of baseball, where strategies like the “opener” can lead to unexpected heroes and the necessity for adaptability on both sides of the field.