The reason Robbie Williams said under-18s should stop being in pop bands after Liam Payne’s death is revealed

Young people under 18 should be prevented from joining major pop bands to protect their mental health, a leading songwriter has said.

Guy Chambers, a good friend of Take That star Robbie Williams, made the comments days after the death of Liam Payne aged 31, who was just 16 when he became part of One Direction in 2010.

Liam, who shares a seven-year-old son with his ex partner Cheryl Tweedy, plunged to his death from the balcony of his hotel room in Buenos Aires, Argentina, on Wednesday.

The singer had previously spoken about his mental health struggles after reaching stardom at such a young age, with many claiming more support should have been given to the boy group in their youth.

Speaking this weekend, Mr Chambers called for the music industry to stop working with talent under the age of 18.

‘I do think putting a 16-year-old in an adult world like that is potentially really damaging. Robbie experienced that, certainly,’ he told the Observer.

Leading songwriter Guy Chambers (right) with Take That star Robbie Williams (left)  in 1999

Leading songwriter Guy Chambers (right) with Take That star Robbie Williams (left)  in 1999

A social media selfie video shows Liam Payne speaking in Sarmiento, Buenos Aires, shortly before his death

A social media selfie video shows Liam Payne speaking in Sarmiento, Buenos Aires, shortly before his death

Liam (centre) was just 16 when he became one fifth of One Direction in 2010

Liam (centre) was just 16 when he became one fifth of One Direction in 2010

Guy Chambers (pictured) called for the music industry to stop working with talent under the age of 18

Guy Chambers (pictured) called for the music industry to stop working with talent under the age of 18

He added: ‘I have four children, so I think about this a lot. I know in Robbie’s case, with Take That, there wasn’t any proper protection set up to look after what were teenage boys.

‘That was a long time ago, but I don’t see much sign of change. There is not much more real care taken, that I have observed, from people involved in the big television talent shows.’

It comes after news that Liam made a shocking admission just minutes before he plunged to his death, MailOnline revealed earlier this week.

A young woman staying in the same hotel said she was told by the former One Direction singer just minutes before he died: ‘I used to be in a boy band – that’s why I’m so f***ed up’.

In her compelling account, Rebecca, one of the last people to speak to the popstar at the Casa Sur Hotel on Wednesday, claimed that Liam showed ‘disturbing and weird behaviour’ as he smashed his laptop on the floor.

Fans of Liam today gathered across the world from London to Paris, New York and Stockholm, to pay tribute to the One Direction star.

Heartbroken fans came together to pay their respects at a vigil at the Peter Pan Statue in Kensington Gardens.

The event was held ‘in memory of Liam’ and to ‘honour his shining spirit and unforgettable impact’.

Bereaved attendees brought flowers, letters, drawings as well as One Direction memorabilia to lay under a picture of the star. Some came in groups and hugged and held each other as they mourned his loss.

In one touching moment, fans sang One Direction’s iconic song ‘What Makes You Beautiful — the band’s lead single from their debut album, ‘Up All Night’.

Related Posts

‘American Idol,’ ‘Shark Tank,’ ‘Celebrity Wheel of Fortune’ and More Unscripted Series Renewed at ABC

‘American Idol,’ ‘Shark Tank,’ ‘Celebrity Wheel of Fortune’ and More Unscripted Series Renewed at ABC ABC has renewed five of its unscripted series for the 2025-2026 television season:…

How Much Do ‘American Idol’ Contestants Get Paid?

How Much Do ‘American Idol’ Contestants Get Paid? Early on contestants have to pay for their own transportation and clothes. Disney/Eric McCandless How Much Do ‘American Idol’…

American Idol’s Top 5 Revealed! Which Duo Didn’t Survive Disney Night?

American Idol’s Top 5 Revealed! Which Duo Didn’t Survive Disney Night? The bad news? With the finale of Season 23 fast approaching in just one week, our…

Hilary Hahn delivered a stunning performance of Sergei Prokofiev’s Violin Concerto No. 1 in D major, Op. 19, showcasing her unparalleled technical mastery and profound emotional depth. With exquisite sensitivity, she brought the intricate layers of the piece to life, weaving a narrative that was both dynamic and deeply moving. From the delicate, dreamlike passages to the fiery intensity of the finale, Hahn guided the audience through a mesmerizing journey, each note brimming with emotion and precision. Her ability to balance technical brilliance with heartfelt expression made this performance an unforgettable musical masterpiece, leaving listeners captivated and inspired.

Hilary Hahn delivered a stunning performance of Sergei Prokofiev’s Violin Concerto No. 1 in D major, Op. 19, showcasing her unparalleled technical mastery and profound emotional depth….

André Rieu and the Johann Strauss Orchestra delivered a breathtaking performance of “Send in the Clowns” in the enchanting setting of Mainau, Germany. The serene atmosphere perfectly complemented Rieu’s heartfelt violin and the orchestra’s lush, harmonious sound, creating a rendition that was as moving as it was unforgettable. Every note was infused with emotion, transforming the iconic piece into a deeply personal and poignant experience for the audience. This spellbinding performance once again highlighted Rieu and his orchestra’s extraordinary ability to connect with listeners on a profound level, leaving everyone in awe of their unmatched artistry and musical magic.

André Rieu and the Johann Strauss Orchestra mesmerized the audience with a spellbinding performance of “Send in the Clowns” in Mainau, Germany. The tranquil setting, paired with…

André Rieu and Donij van Doorn deliver an unforgettable rendition of “Ebben? Ne andrò lontana” from La Wally, captivating the audience with a performance that is both heart-wrenching and breathtakingly beautiful. Van Doorn’s powerful, soul-stirring voice brings Wally’s despair to life, immersing listeners in the raw emotion of the tragic love story. Guided by Rieu’s masterful conducting, the orchestra weaves a delicate yet intense musical tapestry, perfectly complementing the hauntingly beautiful vocals. Every note, every line carries an emotional weight that resonates deeply, transforming this operatic classic into a timeless masterpiece. It’s a performance that transcends time, blending technical brilliance with profound emotion, leaving the audience spellbound and breathless.

André Rieu and Donij van Doorn deliver an unforgettable rendition of “Ebben? Ne andrò lontana” from La Wally, captivating the audience with a performance that is both…