Caitlin Clark is heavy favorite for WNBA rookie of the year. It’s the wrong choice
The Indiana Fever guard has had an impressive first season as a professional. But her old college rival Angel Reese has been consistently excellent
Alex Kirshner
Mon 8 Jul 2024 05.00 EDT
Believe it or not, the WNBA’s most hyped season is halfway finished. The league’s 12 teams are around the midway mark of their 40-game schedules, and the W has storylines galore.
The Las Vegas Aces are gunning for a third consecutive WNBA title behind two-time MVP and defensive player of the year A’ja Wilson, but they find themselves outranked in the standings by the likes of the New York Liberty and Connecticut Sun. Diana Taurasi, 20 years after entering the league in 2004, continues to be an engine in the Phoenix Mercury backcourt. And then, of course, there are the rookies.
Caitlin Clark of the Indiana Fever may already be the most famous women’s basketball player ever. Her old college rival, Chicago Sky’s Angel Reese, has become a household name in her own right. In very different ways, the two players have come to headline a rollicking rookie of the year race. Here’s the tale of the tape – so far.
Caitlin Clark, guard, Indiana Fever
The argument for: Clark is not carrying the WNBA on her back, exactly, as much as she’s building on the progress the league spent years making before she came along. But she is still the league’s biggest draw. Her every move is scrutinized – often by those with an agenda beyond basketball – and, as with every star rookie, opponents work tirelessly to shake her up. But Clark has generally handled the limelight well while still conjuring a bit of magic on the court. She just became the first rookie in league history to post a triple-double when she produced 19 points, 13 assists, and 12 rebounds in a win against the Liberty on Saturday. Her prodigious playmaking ability has been on frequent display: Clark is third in the WNBA with 7.4 assists per game, despite playing on a team that was bad enough to get the first overall pick two years running. She’ll only get better from here, so her case for rookie of the year should get stronger as the season winds on.
Angel Reese, forward, Chicago Sky
The argument for: It’s simple: Reese has been the best rookie in the WNBA up to this point in the season. The 6ft 3in forward has been utterly dominant as a rebounder, her calling card going back to a decorated college career at Maryland and LSU. Reese’s 21.3 total rebounding percentage through Saturday was the best in the entire league among regular rotation players. She is a disruptive force in the middle of the Chicago defense, and she manages to score plenty of points too, as demonstrated by an ongoing streak of 13 double-doubles. That streak isn’t just a rookie record but a record for the whole history of the WNBA. Not bad for a first-year player. Reese has done it all while dealing with her own media circus and intense public focus on everything she says and does. By both conventional stats and advanced numbers like win shares, Reese rules all WNBA rookies comfortably.
The argument against: It’s not a very good one at this point. Reese should be the frontrunner, even though betting markets are only slowly warming up to the idea of someone other than Clark winning the award. But if you want to play devil’s advocate, Reese adds almost no value as a perimeter shooter and is not a polished finisher around the basket. Her rebounding totals, excellent as they are, have long been inflated by Reese’s many opportunities to collect her own misses around the basket. She had plenty such chances at LSU, where she shot 47.1% from the field in her senior season. She has had plenty more with the Sky, where she has shot 41%. Taking almost all of her shots from around the basket, unlike Clark, has given Reese chances to follow up and increase her rebounding totals without necessarily being efficient. Clark doesn’t get the same stat-padding opportunities around the rim and has less margin for error in her pursuit of efficiency, so perhaps the Fever guard should get some extra leeway in evaluating her early stat lines.
Rickea Jackson, guard, Los Angeles Sparks
The argument for: Life’s more interesting when there is a spoiler in the mix. There is only the most remote chance of someone not named Clark or Reese winning the award. The other most likely candidate may be Chicago center Kamilla Cardoso, but she faces two problems – injury kept her out of a handful of games in the season’s early going, and she shares a frontcourt with Reese, who is clearly a better candidate. So any unlikely interloper would have to come from elsewhere, and Jackson fits the bill. She’s the only other rookie to average double figures in scoring (10.4 points per game) and has done so with more efficient shooting numbers than Clark or Reese, and has far fewer turnovers than Clark.
The argument against: Well, you get it. Reese and Clark are making everyone else’s cases moot.
News
Riley Gaines CRITICIZES Brittney Griner for kneeling during the National Anthem
In a passionate statement, Riley Gaines has taken a strong stance against Brittney Griner for her decision to kneel during the National Anthem. Gaines, known for her…
VIDEO: Angel Reese Broke The Internet By Shaking Her Booty In Tiny Two-Piece Bikini While Poolside During WNBA All-Star Weekend
WNBA rookie forward Angel Reese is a star both on and off the floor. Before the playing of the All-Star game, the Chicago Sky rookie was in the sun soaking up…
Brittney Griner ‘screams’ after Kid Rock bluntly criticizes: ‘If you don’t respect America, you don’t deserve to represent this place’… See in comments
In a recent controversy that has sparked heated debate across social media, basketball star Brittney Griner found herself at the center of criticism from musician Kid Rock….
Caitlin Clark Had The Coolest Reaction To Being Called A “White B****” By Pat McAfee
Caitlin Clark and Pat McAfee (Photos via Getty Images) Caitlin Clark has offered a reaction to being called a “White B-” by Pat McAfee, according to Pat Mcafee himself. …
Controversy Erupts as Caitlin Clark Punched by Angel Reese, Resulting in Flagrant 1 Foul. Fans Debate Referee Bias on Social Media
Angel Reese and Caitlin Clark (Photo by Emilee Chinn/Getty Images) Chicago Sky rookie Angel Reese reacted to Los Angeles Sparks rookie Cameron Brink tearing her ACL and effectively…
BREAKING: Aliyah Bostoп shocked social media after speakiпg oυt that she doesп’t waпt Caitliп Clark to be modest after her triple-doυble bυt to be coпfideпt aпd boast loυdly to motivate her teammates, excitiпg the faпs…wow
Aliyah Boston wasn’t about to let Caitlin Clark get into her habit of being quiet and humble. While Clark’s M.O. To acknowledge your teammates instead of looking…
End of content
No more pages to load