Shocking Upset: Jeopardy! Fans Left Reeling as Brad Rutter's Masters Performance Falls Flat – A Legendary Contestant's Stunning Decline Sparks Outrage and Disappointment Among Devoted Viewers!

‘Jeopardy!’ Fans React to Brad Rutter’s Disappointing ‘Masters’ Performance

Jeopardy!/ABC/YouTube

Season 3 of Jeopardy! Masters got off to a shocking start on Wednesday when Brad Rutter, the highest-winning Jeopardy! contestant of all time, came in last on the premiere. The game show contestant seemed to keep good spirits and still riff on host Ken Jennings despite his loss, but fans had mixed reactions and said Rutter was rusty.

Ritter competed against the 2024 Masters champion Victoria Groce, from Macon, Georgia, and the 2024 Tournament of Champions winner Yogesh Raut, during the first game, on Wednesday, April 30.

When Jennings introduced the contestants, he said that he was meeting Rutter, an actor, for the first time on opposite sides of the podium. “I know you’re thrilled to see me, Ken,” Rutter said. “Always a delight, Brad,” Jennings replied.

He was the only one to answer a question wrong in the first round. During the interview round, Rutter said that he has been staying sharp, even though fans can’t tell because he hasn’t been quick on the buzzer. “Any other goals for the tournament?” Jennings asked him. “I think I want to make fun of you some,” he replied. “Fair enough. That’s why I’m here,” Jennings said. “I’m always looking for opportunities,” Rutter responded. “I’m sure I will give you many. It’s great to see you again, Brad,” the host said.

By the end of the game, Rutter only had $6,200. He didn’t know the Final Jeopardy question, so he dropped down to $2,178. Being in third gave him zero points, and when the standings were revealed at the end, Rutter was in last place. He will be back in later matchups to try and redeem himself. Once all nine players have competed once, the lineup mixes up. Track the tournament here.

Fans were disappointed in Rutter’s gameplay, especially since he is one of the Greatest of All Time, and reacted online.

“Surprised people are completely writing Brad off already. Yogesh and Victoria have to be one of the most difficult matchups you can get–especially for your first game back after a few years. I’m not saying he’s going to smoke whoever he gets in his second game. But I’m not eulogizing him quite yet,” a Reddit user said.

“Perhaps he may do a lot better in his second game, and I agree this was a brutal matchup, but prior to the GOAT tournament it was also true that Brad never really had much of a problem against even the toughest competition, and now he’s practically not even in the same game as them. He may or may not come back, but it’s pretty much impossible to deny that he’s clearly lost his touch a little,” wrote another.

“It’s still early in the tournament, but I genuinely feel bad for Brad. :(,” said a third.

“Not sure if Brad is just out of practice or if time has just gotten the better of him, but this isn’t great for him. It is somewhat frustrating as a viewer that it feels like the game at this level is a buzzer race that happens to have trivia questions in between,” commented a fan.

“Brad just doesn’t have it anymore. Hate to say it but it’s true. He’s an amazing player and he should always command respect for being the only contestant for a long time to have it out for Ken on the Jeopardy stage, but his buzzer skills and reflexes have clearly slowed significantly over the years,” one last fan said.

See X users react below.

brad rutter in last place on jeopardy masters… pic.twitter.com/4t0PzJQtUz

— Zee. (@forbestiel) May 1, 2025

I got the first Final Jeopardy on Jeopardy Masters correct and the great Brad Rutter (my Jeopardy hero) didn’t. I might have peaked.

— Jeffrey Cook (@NagusCook) May 1, 2025